How to Build a Winning Blue Collar Company Culture: Jake Wattenbarger
Quick answer: Jake Wattenbarger, President and General Manager of Smith & Oby (a Foundral company), walks through his unconventional path from military service into leading one of the Midwest’s most respected mechanical contracting companies. Listen to the full episode below.
Meet the Guest
- Jake Wattenbarger: LinkedIn, Website: smithandoby.com
Jake Wattenbarger, President and General Manager of Smith & Oby (a Foundral company), walks through his unconventional path from military service into leading one of the Midwest’s most respected mechanical contracting companies. This conversation covers the 125+ year history of Smith & Oby, the real challenges of finding and keeping skilled tradespeople, and the cultural shifts reshaping the construction industry.
Jake breaks down the three core reasons employees leave a company and the retention framework he’s built around culture, operations and growth. We dig into how to speak to different audiences with sincerity, the intentionality behind strong client relationships and why caring is the underrated leadership skill that separates good managers from great ones. He also shares his take on drug policies, AI’s impact on the trades and what young people need to hear about career advancement.
What This Episode Covers:
Jake’s journey from military service to mechanical contracting, plus the legacy of Smith & Oby. Insights into skilled labor shortages, hiring for character over credentials, and industry shifts. Why employees leave—and how alignment, clarity, and trust fix it. The role of culture, operations, and growth in retention. Communication strategies across teams and building strong client relationships. Hot topics like drug policies, AI in the trades, and leadership that actually cares. Practical advice for young professionals looking to grow in the trades.
Chapters:
00:00 — Introduction and Background 05:05 — Historical Perspective and Evolution of Mechanical Contracting 10:15 — Discussion on Education and Career Paths 19:14 — Investing in Talent and Work Ethic 25:12 — The Three Pillars of Retention 01:07:44 — Career Advancement
About Our Guest:
Jake Wattenbarger is the President and General Manager of The Smith & Oby Company, a 125+ year old Midwest-based HVAC and plumbing mechanical contracting firm serving healthcare, education, commercial & industrial, and civic markets. A northeast Ohio native and Youngstown State University graduate, Jake brings over 24 years of engineering, project management, and commercial construction experience to the role.
Before taking the helm at Smith & Oby, Jake served in the United States Army and U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, and held leadership positions at Next Generation Construction, Sodexo, Zurich North America, and the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs. His military background, technical depth, and people-first leadership style have made him a go-to voice on what it actually takes to attract, retain, and develop skilled trades talent in today’s construction industry.
Connect with Jake Wattenbarger: LinkedIn:
https://www.linkedin.com/in/jakewattenbarger/
Smith & Oby Website (a Foundral company): https://smithandoby.com/
Contact Us:
Looking to hire skilled trade talent or find your next opportunity? Visit us at https://www.thebluecollarrecruiter.com
Have a guest suggestion or want to come on the show? Reach out — we’re always looking for the next great conversation in the trades.
Full Episode Transcript
Leadership Longevity and the President’s Wall
Troy Latuff: All right, welcome to the Blue Collar Trade Show, everybody, and welcome, Jake Wadenberger. How are doing today? Thank you for joining the show.
Jake Wattenbarger: doing well.
Troy Latuff: Thank you, thank you. All right, so ⁓ Jake, we’re really excited to have you on. You’ve come looking at your business and what you all do is pretty amazing. But before we get into some of that, tell us a little bit about you. Just kind of tell us a little bit about your background and what you’re doing today.
Jake Wattenbarger: Yeah, so ⁓ I was born and raised in Northeast Ohio, about 30 miles south of Youngstown. ⁓ Yeah, I went to Youngstown State. I got my degree in civil engineering. I always wanted to serve, so I got a scholarship through ROTC. I got immediate active duty. I spent about five years in the Army and about three years active duty. And then from there, I kind of decided that I’d rather practice freedom rather than defend it. And so I went on the civilian side.
Marissa: Thank
Jake Wattenbarger: and still working for the Army Corps of Engineers and Department of Veteran Affairs at the 15 year mark of government work, I decided to go to private sector. And then from that side, I was more on the owner side, ⁓ still in construction. And then being on, I say the owner side, so ⁓ that’s like the end client. for construction and then I spent some time as an owner’s agent and then as a construction manager and then finally now I’m on the subcontractor side. So I have a unique perspective. I’ve seen it from all angles.
Troy Latuff: Yeah.
Jake Wattenbarger: And right now, being ⁓ as a subcontractor, when I was on the owner side, the CMs wanted to be your friends. And then when you’re a CM, the subcontractors want to be your friend. And as you’re a subcontractor, the vendors and suppliers want to be your friends. So it all changes the dynamics.
Troy Latuff: Yeah. Sure.
Chad: Yep.
Marissa: Thank
Jim Nichols: So basically what I’ve gotten from this so far is you get along with everybody.
Marissa: Yeah.
Jake Wattenbarger: ⁓ Get along or a lot of conflict with everybody, however you want to phrase it, but yeah. Yeah.
Jim Nichols: the
Troy Latuff: Depends on the day. All right, so it’s interesting, right? So you’ve done that, you were in the army, Jim, Jim is a Navy guy, so I’m sure he has a couple of potshots for you, but we’ll save that for later, Jim. Usually you come at it, but we’ll wait. All right, so anyway, so tell us how you got it. you know, when I’m looking at your business, I was looking at your website, what’s the elevator pitch when you’re sitting at a friend’s house or at the, you know.
Jim Nichols: Okay.
Troy Latuff: somewhere and somebody says, what do do Jake? How do you explain it?
Jake Wattenbarger: Yeah, you know, I, there’s really no, no really short answer, but try to try to make a break. Yeah, you can. It’s like, we, have a lot of things. so one, you know, we’re a mechanical contractor. We’ve been in business since 1898. We have a proud history. and it’s always been privately owned and they’ve only had maybe like eight to 10 CEOs or presidents and, and, ⁓ yeah.
Troy Latuff: That’s what I was kind of wondering if they’re looking at it’s like, how do you explain this? Is that right? In all that time? In 130 years? Wow.
Jake Wattenbarger: Yeah, 128 years, maybe it’s been like 10 or something. Yeah. When I look at the president’s wall, yeah, I mean, some of these folks were there for like 40 years. So yeah, they do have a big snap of time. And some of them were more like five, six years. But anyway, so we have on the mechanical contracting side, we take these big, you know, iconic projects in the Cleveland market. We’ve done stuff at the… ⁓ Sherman Williams headquarters, downtown is the skyscraper. That’s the newest one. We did the R &D for Sherman Williams. We’ve done stuff, all kinds of work at the Cleveland Clinic, university hospitals, ⁓ a lot of other, you we did the Cuyahoga Juvenile ⁓ Justice Center. We did that one. We did the ⁓ federal courthouse downtown. It’s another skyscraper. ⁓ And it just, it just continues. And then we have on the service side, this is where we do We have a lot of technicians that after you build it, now you got to maintain it and you got to problem solve. So we’ve got that crew running around. Now we also have a group down and that’s this is in the Cleveland area. Then we have another group down there in Charleston, West Virginia called DSO, which is under the Smith and Obey umbrella. Smith and Obey bought, ⁓ did an acquisition back in 2012 and they do the same. They just do it in the Charleston, West Virginia market. But they get a lot of the horsepower. here at Cleveland. This is where we have a lot of our engineers and our coordinators and really robust estimators. We also have a sheet metal shop and a pipe shop. They have a sheet metal shop down in Charleston, West Virginia, but we have a big one where we’ve got around 35 office people. Then we’ve got about 215 that I’ve classified. Those are our union folks. So we’ve got, and they’re all, Predominantly plumbers and sheet metal workers. And then we also have plumbers. Yeah, I would say 75 % of our work is construction. 25 % of our work is service.
Troy Latuff: service. Yeah. Well, so I’m thinking so I was, you know, I’m you look you look a little too young to be around since 1898. But I wonder what they were doing in 1898. Eight as mechanical contractors. What does that look like? Boilers mostly? What do you think it was steam?
Jake Wattenbarger: Yeah, well, you know, I think they started off. Yeah, they worked a lot at Case Western Reserve University, who’s still a big client of ours, and the Cleveland Clinic. They still did work back then too, when they just initially started. But yeah, they were more of a, I think they were more of a plumbing, and then they migrated to more of pipe fitting. And then now, you know, and then we got into the sheet metal, and now we do all three. but it did shift from more on the plumbing side. And depending on where you’re at, depending, know, at least in the Cleveland market, ⁓ medical gas is claimed by the plumbers. If you go into other markets, it’s actually claimed by the pipe fitters. So some of them have separate unions. Some of them have combined locals. We, in the Charleston market, we have combined where the fitters and the plumbers are in the same. A pair in Cleveland, no, they’re separate. They are separate markets and they’ve got separate rules and collecting bargaining agreements and the way they do things. So another level of complexity. So yeah, kind of a long-winded answer that it’s complicated.
Troy Latuff: It’s complicated. Yeah. Well, it’s, it’s interesting because I it’s, ⁓ a lot’s the same, but a lot’s different, a lot more bureaucracy today than it was probably 130 years ago. But I was part of a, a small mom and pop, nothing like what you’re talking about, but a small mom and pop plumbing business that was around it incorporated in this is up in the twin cities. ⁓ it incorporated in 1944, but there was the, the, the, the owners had business prior to that. And when we went in to do some remodeling, we would pull out some old pipe that the plumbers would weld their initials in, like OKC or whatever, that we knew was from like 1918, 1920. mean, old, old stuff that we would pull out that they tattooed, right? So it was really kind of fun.
Jake Wattenbarger: Thank you. It’s funny that you say that, you we were doing a project at the, I think it was at the Union Club, which is a older building that’s probably been around since, you know, 1920 or 1940 or something, downtown Cleveland, it’s like a social club. Well, anyway, we were doing some work there, our service department, and they pulled out an old valve. And the valve that we pulled out, we put it in one of our, we have an old safe that where they actually used to use this and didn’t used to go to the bank, they used to put all the money, we still have it.
Why Moving Up Lets You Influence Change
Troy Latuff: ⁓ my God.
Jake Wattenbarger: It’s enormous, that Smith and Nobe, it’s all over it. Anyway, so I put this valve in the safe. And I guess back then, as when you would wanna do advertising and marketing, you could pay extra to the vendor and you could have your emblem put inside of the valve. And we’ve got a Smith and Nobe valve that was there. So I put that in the safe. I kind of get that stamp, very similar. Yeah.
Troy Latuff: Yeah? Isn’t that crazy? Yeah, very, I always be branding. That’s what they say, right? So, okay, so I’ll kick off a couple of questions here. So as we dig in and you three certainly chime in, but so, you you didn’t just fall into this role. So tell us a little bit how you got to where you’re at today. mean, so what, give us the little bit of the chain of events of what transpired to get you to where you are.
Chad: Wow.
Jim Nichols: That’s cool.
Chad: Good.
Marissa: That is so crazy.
Chad: Yeah.
Jake Wattenbarger: Yeah, well, you sometimes, you you fall into it. I don’t know, sometimes you do fall into some things. I think throughout my career, you know, I’ve been pretty, yeah, I’ve been pretty well rounded and I look at all of my experience that have led me up to this event.
Troy Latuff: Sometimes, yeah. It’s keeping your eyes open to it, right? It really is.
Jake Wattenbarger: I’ve always wanted to be in a position of increased responsibility so you can have more influence to really influence that change. And as you go up in your career, you find yourself, wow, would change this if I was in charge. I would change this and you, now that I’ve kind of worked my way up, being a project manager, a program manager, a director, a vice president, now the president of the company, now I’m in a position that I can learn from all that and do it. And it wasn’t planned. I always wanted to be an influencer and change things. And this one is just an opportunity. You know, it came up and the timing was right. I interviewed for it and I ended up being the president and general manager of Smith and Obey. We’re a Hamer at now, which is it’ll be three years in November. ⁓ And it was, you know, it was a big a big change. I’ve I’ve I’ve been involved in big organizations, but when you’re the head person, ⁓ now it’s time to take everything that you’ve learned. and really ⁓ set out what you were meant to do the way I look at that. And I just took all that experience and I looked at really the three pillars that I looked at. You gotta look at the culture, right? You gotta look at operations and you gotta look at growth. I always remember a quote from Peter Drunker, he said, ⁓ culture eats strategy for breakfast and how absolutely true.
Troy Latuff: Mm-hmm.
Jake Wattenbarger: That’s kind of now, you know, so, and I’ve just kind of lived to that. It’s not complicated, but it’s hard work.
Troy Latuff: Yeah.
Chad: What about this trade specifically, Jake? Like I’m from the great state of Ohio as well. I’m opposite corner of you like Dayton, Cincinnati area. And where I grew up, it was just part of our culture to get into the trades, especially my family. Was it similar to eat for you?
Jake Wattenbarger: It was, you I grew up about, you know, 30 miles south of Youngstown and a lot of, you know, my dad was a mechanic. My mother was a teacher, ⁓ but we’re kind of in a rural area. So most of the neighborhood that I grew in there, they’re the dads with the truck drivers or they worked at Ors Town, which was a GM plant or in some of the other companies. And before that, it was a steel industry before the steel industry collapse and all those things. So yeah, they would definitely go into, go into the trades. ⁓ I think, you know, my parents, like, they wanted us to go to college and try to be
Chad: Mm-hmm.
Jake Wattenbarger: a little bit more and we did that. ⁓ And so my brother and I ended up just going into college, but I have several friends that have been as successful, if not more successful, that have went into the trades.
Chad: That’s interesting. We talk a lot about that on this show, about ⁓ the myth of college or some of the misunderstandings about college.
Jake Wattenbarger: I would say college is, you probably spend more time unlearning what you learned because it doesn’t, it’s just a waste of time. I see, you know, everybody’s, you know, they was like, hey, you go back and get your master’s degree. Like, why? I don’t even use my bachelor’s degree. Why would I go back and do that? I was like, it’s on the job training. You’re like, oh, do you have your MBA? No, but I’ve run a business. know a PLL and a cash statement and balance, you know, what the balance sheet looks like. It’s not, you if you’re an engineer or you’re a problem solver, it’s not terribly complicated.
Marissa: Do you have anything?
Jim Nichols: Right,
Chad: Thank Ain’t that the truth?
Troy Latuff: So do you talk people out of it? Do you talk people out of it? I mean, there’s a place for it, obviously, but what are your, know, somebody is asking you, how do you kind of discern whether they should go one way or the other, if they’re asking for your advice?
Jake Wattenbarger: You just have to take the time to work. Yeah, I always look at the cost benefit analysis. Like, okay, well, what do you want to be when you grow up? What is it? And then is your employer going to pay for it? If they’re not, then they don’t put much value into it. And if they do, then do the hard work and you can leverage it. There’s always opportunity that you can learn from experiences within everything. But at the same time, you don’t have to go to college to be a successful business owner. Matter of fact, you the previous folks out of here and one of the most successful ones was a pipe fitter and went through the ranks, became a project manager and then the COO and then the CEO and all the people in industry that are our competitors, they didn’t go to college. They own their own business and they’re extremely successful. And I can tell you, they are so sharp on business development.
Chad: I love it.
Jake Wattenbarger: and on their estimates and how to read people and how to be profitable on jobs and how to push ⁓ various, you know, ⁓ your foreman have to, they know how to push their foreman and they know how to push their journeyman and their apprentices because our biggest risk on projects is labor. You gotta beat those labor hours. We know the equipment, we know the price for the equipment, we know it for the materials, but labor is our biggest risk. But it’s also our biggest opportunity for profit.
Troy Latuff: variable.
Chad: Yeah, sure. ⁓ I love that, man. I mean, I just wish that that was, that’s why we talk about a lot of the show and hopefully our platform reaches some people’s ears about that because a lot of these kids are getting sucked into that belief system that college is the answer. And like Troy advocates, it definitely has a place, but it’s not the end all be all, is it?
Troy Latuff: Yeah, well, so with that, know, so and we’ve all outside of Marissa, right, who’s a couple years younger than us. ⁓ feels like, you know, so when we were, I don’t know about my parents or grandparents, but I know when I was in school, high school particularly, you know, they did, it was a pretty, and I grew up in an area like you all, right? More blue collar-ish than some of these other areas. ⁓ And it was a pretty even mix, right? go to college, go to trade school, go to the military. And it didn’t, you know, it didn’t seem quite as pressured to do one or the other. Right. And then it kind of had a, in my view, at least a pretty big pendulum shift to if you don’t go to college, you’re going to fail. And then some areas it says, my wife and I talk about all the time in some areas, not only is it don’t go to, if you don’t go to college, you’re going to fail. If you don’t go to this exact college, you’re going to fail. That’s, that’s where my head pops off, but
Investing in Talent and Training the Team
Jim Nichols: Absolutely.
Chad: Yeah.
Jim Nichols: Sure.
Chad: What a crap.
Troy Latuff: Do you see a pendulum shifting the other way back to maybe when we were younger?
Jake Wattenbarger: I do see the pendulum swinging a little bit more. I sit on the GATC, the Joint Apprentice Training Council for the pipe fitters here in Cleveland. And we have to interview all the apprentices, or we have to interview everybody so before they get into the union and to come in as an apprentice. And I can tell you, it’s extremely competitive. We got 300 applicants and we got 12 slots that go in. Yeah.
Jim Nichols: Wow, really?
Chad: That’s nice, man. Excellent.
Jake Wattenbarger: Yeah, now my thing is like, can we increase the 12 to like 24 or 30? What are we doing? There’s a bottleneck here, but I don’t want to get into politics. but yeah, there, there’s definitely should be pushing more people through. But at the same time, you know, we have seen some of the work ethics and the quality. comes with a double edged sword. want to go and they think it’s the easy route. It’s not, you got to pay your dues. And I know this is a cultural thing, but I have seen, you know, I asked some of our foremen and our superintendents. So like, Hey, we got a good apprentice here. Like what really?
Jim Nichols: No kidding. Yeah.
Marissa: Thank
Chad: Yeah.
Jake Wattenbarger: educate me what makes them good. Well, they show up on time. Okay, well what else? Well, they don’t call off. Okay, what else? Well, they keep their cell phone in their pocket. I’m like, is that it? Yeah. That’s just, that’s good. That’s like great. Yeah. It doesn’t take much to be above average. If you’ve got a little bit of work ethic, can not only, you can excel. The hard part is getting, you know, one of those spots if you’re 300 and you got to be patient.
Marissa: you
Chad: They stand out. Yeah, they stand out now.
Troy Latuff: It was good, it was good not that long ago.
Jim Nichols: You did. Yeah.
Jake Wattenbarger: And if you’re patient, you’ll eventually get in. But it also, you gotta do stuff to improve yourself to make yourself more marketable. So you get moved up on that list.
Troy Latuff: So what do you tell the other 288? What advice do you give them?
Chad: See you on time.
Jake Wattenbarger: Yeah, well, sometimes, you know, it’s a different path. You’ll notice that if you go on the construction side, ⁓ you’re like, hey, have you ever thought of going on the service side? You can always switch later. ⁓ I don’t want to do that. Service technicians can actually make more than some of the construction guys. So they’re like, really? It’s like, yeah, you get your own van. You’re running around. can, it’s pretty much just you once you work your way up and ⁓ you’ll be very successful. So sometimes there’s
Jim Nichols: Absolutely.
Jake Wattenbarger: There’s different ways to get to the same result. And that’s some of the best advice you get. You gotta look at it. And so, know, some folks are like, well, maybe I’ll go into sheet metal or I’ll go into this or I’ll go into that. Sometimes you have to, if there’s a bottleneck in some of the trades, you know, this is that opportunity. Sometimes five years is a big deal to wait. And I’m like, I’m not waiting that long. I got to pivot. And that’s Yep.
Troy Latuff: Yeah, yeah, there’s a lot of other things. ⁓
Jim Nichols: So what, with what you’re doing now, I mean, as far as the, the hiring side of it, how difficult is it for you now to find the people you need? Are you struggling to fill your slots or?
Jake Wattenbarger: It’s hard to find new folks. really, know, your companies that get all their folks from the union, I look at this way, it’s, they’re supposed to be your broker for labor, right? ⁓ And if you know, any, if anytime, if you send people back to the bench and they’re really, really good, they’re gonna get snatched up by your competitors. So you don’t wanna do that. So you’ve gotta balance things out of how that… how that works. And so we found that we always have to have our core people, our foremen and our superintendents, and we identify someone that are really good journeymen. We want to do everything we can to keep them. Once they go to the bench, you know, they go. But if there’s nobody on the bench and you need more people, we found that we, know, the union doing what they can, but we found you got to be in contact with those business agents and you got to unionize your own, your own force, your own forces.
Troy Latuff: Yeah.
Jake Wattenbarger: And when we found that we can find some non-union folks, we can take their experience, we can fast track them in and get them in. And we’ve been successful. I think we did about seven or eight last year. So we have to do that. It’s more on the technician side, not on the construction side, but at least on the technician side, we typically, and that’s really where our biggest demand is, is on the technicians, not on the construction.
Troy Latuff: So when you’re looking for that sort of talent, what kind of criteria do you use? What kind of advice do you give? Any young people listening, what are you looking for, right? If somebody says, hey, I want to become part of your team, join the union, all that kind of stuff. And you said, you
Jake Wattenbarger: Yeah, you know, and some of this stuff is, it’s just, it’s stuff that you really don’t have to be, it’s stuff that you can do right away. Be a person of your word. Show up, you know, just as you say, like if you have an appointment at, you know, let’s say at eight o’clock, be there at 7.45, right? If you’re gonna work, don’t be clockwork on the clock. No, you work extra. You do that little bit extra. If you do those things, those little things, you are gonna stand out and you’ll be able to have opportunities and you will move on. That’s all you really need. You just need to be proactive and not be scared to have some hard work. And if you do, that’s nice.
Troy Latuff: How do you measure that though? How do you measure that in an interview? Right? Because there’s mechanical ability and then there’s
Jake Wattenbarger: You don’t, yeah, you’re not gonna do that. Yeah, you’re not gonna do that in interviews, a skill, right? And anybody can do that. It’s really get them in there, test them out. And then if they don’t, you move them out. You gotta get them out. And trust me, you will know fairly quickly and you gotta move fast. But we usually won’t go that, yeah, we’ll do some interviews. But typically you find out where they worked from before and their references and nine times out of 10, if they got good references and where they’re coming from, you’re gonna be good.
Troy Latuff: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Jake Wattenbarger: And then from there, when we take them and we get them into the union, it usually works out fine.
Troy Latuff: Yeah. Do you find that there? So on the services side, you know, so there’s in Chad’s business, not to speak for him, but I’ve been in that world for a long, long time too. But it’s almost to a point where you can hire or we’re willing to train the tech. they’re mechanically capable, right? We can train the technical as long as they bring the, the, the, ⁓ character qualities that were before. Right. So do you, is that the same on the commercial side? Would you say?
Jim Nichols: Character,
Jake Wattenbarger: It is, and what typically what you do, you you, gotta get guys trained. You have to invest in your talent. And so you, and that’s one of the things, you know, that we do. And I came on board, you know, we did a survey. One of the things that we found within my first 90 days, we found communication and training. So you had to act upon that survey and get these guys trained, including the technicians. Some of them gravitate more to control. Some of them will want to be a chiller. Some of them want to be this, get them the training that they need. And then more important, you know, when these guys are apprentices, is that team them up with a good journeyman or a good supervisor and they’re gonna teach them. They’re gonna teach them everything that they need to know. And yeah, then they’ll be fine. But it takes time. They’re not gonna come in right away. ⁓ It’s an investment. And I think as an employer, you have to invest in your talent. It kind of goes both ways. If they’re gonna work hard for you, you have to invest in them.
Why People Leave: Alignment, Clarity and Trust
Chad: Absolutely. So this miss that we’re getting sometimes with our people, ⁓ you’ve been in the game for a while. Has it always been there or do you see it increasing generationally?
Jim Nichols: What did?
Troy Latuff: ⁓
Jake Wattenbarger: When you say miss on what, ⁓ please clarify, Chad.
Chad: The showing up right at 8 o’clock or 8.02 on their phone all the time. mean, you know, we sometimes argue back and forth that this has always been a problem. I’d like to hear what you have to say about it.
Jake Wattenbarger: Yeah, you know, we all, you know, we all live in our own bubbles. So it’s tough to me, but I can tell you how I grew up where I came from. And even when I was in the army, you know, everybody, but I’m some, a certain generation and I was raised a certain way. ⁓ yeah, you show up early, you work extra, you say, yes, sir, you know, no ma’am or whatever else, you know, you, you, you call people by Mr. or Mrs. You didn’t use their first names. You were very respectful to adults, regardless of who they were. And I noticed that culturally it has changed, you know, with my kids sports, they don’t do that. You know, they don’t call me sir. Hey, what’s going Like you don’t have the privilege to call me by my first name. Back it up. Like I am Mr. Wattenberger. I am not Jake to you. It was like, ah, you know, where people will, you know, I’ve had times he went out in the military when I, before I got out, I remember I was coming off of a…
Marissa: Thank
Jake Wattenbarger: I was coming off staff duty, so I was pulling up, you know, almost 24 hours of no sleep and I’m pulling in and I got stuck behind the school bus. And I’m still in my uniform and these kids, they’re spilling out of the school bus because they’re going to an apartment building. I lived in the other apartment around the corner. And this kid, you know, they refuse to get out of the way. And so I rolled down my window and was like, hey, gentlemen, can you get out to the left or to the right? Kid flipped me off. Oh, yeah. So I pulled over.
Chad: What?
Marissa: Thank
Jake Wattenbarger: I was like, huh, I grabbed them. say, where do you live? ⁓ I’m sorry, sir. ⁓ no, no, no, no, there’s no sorry now. Where do you live? We’re going to go, I’m going to grab hold of you and take charge and do that. I would have in my, in my neighborhood, we would have never done that. But towards the end of my career, well, I, I, well, this was in Georgia. So I was stationed down at Fort Stewart. So I did it outside of, I was outside of Savannah. So I did it then, but yeah, but I did see, you know, the, the gen,
Chad: Well, I’m proud to see that you can still do that in Ohio.
Troy Latuff: Yeah
Chad: Okay.
Troy Latuff: Did you bring him to his house?
Jake Wattenbarger: No, no, no, I knocked on his on his door of the apartment building and of course, nobody was there. No surprise. Yeah. So again, ⁓
Jim Nichols: That’s, you know, it’s so funny. You talk about that. And I remember when I was, I did 21 in the Navy, but I was home on recruiting duty and I went back to my high school and go in and see the principal. And I was talking to him and you know, Mr. Hart was his name. He said, you know, Jimmy, now, now you can call me Larry. No, sir. I don’t think I’ll ever call you Larry. You’re going to remain Mr. Hart.
Chad: Hmm
Troy Latuff: Yeah
Jim Nichols: Yeah, so I know what you’re talking about. Go ahead, Chad. Well, I was just going to ask about with your company, is retention a big factor? I know with the union, it’s slightly different, but maybe on the service side, are you? And what do you see as a good, for companies that are doing things really, really well, what is
Chad: Well, they’ve got to… Go ahead. No, I’m not…
Jim Nichols: What is a good retention model, if you will? What keeps people at a company?
Jake Wattenbarger: Yeah, so I think it’s layered. I look at people typically leave, they leave a company one because of three reasons, right? It’s lack of alignment, it’s lack of clarity and it’s lack of trust. And when I say alignment, like, hey, I don’t know where we’re going. I don’t know how I fit into this organization. When you have clarity, I have no idea what my roles and responsibilities are. then… Then you get the mismatch, hey, I’m overworked, I’m underpaid. And then you get into trust. That’s all about your management team. Are they a person of their word? Do they break their promises? Do they have your back when it’s needed? One, if not all of those three things, that’s why people leave. If you can solve those three things, they’re not gonna leave. Now there’s a lot of different ways to do it, but I look at it from really kind of three pillars. of those three things, I’m looking at culture, I’m looking at operations, and I’m looking at growth. So for retention, I think it kind of lives in there. And this goes for office employees and the field employees. When I look at, ⁓ you know, for the culture, I think this is kind of where some of the alignment lives, you know, they need to know how they kind of fit in the organization and where they’re going. And then when it goes into I would say for operations, now you can go into your roles and responsibilities, your KPIs, know, kind of means and methods. And then you go into your growth and this is a lot of that, you know, about your leadership and about your trust. Hey, are you going to invest in me? Is there some kind of ⁓ plan for me to progress in this company? And then if that is, what does that look like? Why do I want to stay here? And, you know, when I first came on at Smith and Obey, I took the first 90 days because they had some mismanagement here and people were counting days until their non-competes were up and we lost some good folks. And I understood why because it was one, if not all of those three things. And so when I came on board, I’m like, ⁓ man, I need to fix this. And one of the first things I did, I did a SWOT analysis, I did a survey so I understood what was going on. And I realized we have a major culture problem here. people have no idea where this company is going and there’s a lack of trust. All those three things that I said about alignment, clarity and trust, it wasn’t there. So I had to get all these folks back on board, not only to retain who I’ve got, but also attract talent. ⁓ And one of the first things that I did, after that survey, then I had to act upon it. When I acted upon it, I knew communication was a problem.
Jim Nichols: Right.
Jake Wattenbarger: And I knew lack of training was a problem from the survey, but I also know talking from various folks that there were some other problems going on too. You know, they like, I don’t know what I’m doing. Where are we going? And Hey, so I updated the org chart. I came up with position descriptions, working with the management team of what everybody’s roles and responsibilities are. And then to my surprise, I found out that some of these folks had additional responsibilities, but they were way underpaid. So what an opportunity. So now I had to look like, on, well, guys, I think you’re underpaid. I’m going to do a markets analysis and you’re going to help me. Hey, I found five data points that say you should be paid this. Do you agree or disagree? I agree with you or I disagree. Well, find me another data point and I’ll be in your corner and I’ll support you. And so I got all that fixed. So I fixed their roles and responsibilities. They understood it. And then I got them paid and I got them back paid for it too, from when they took to that immediately changed everything around. So now my management team was behind me.
Jim Nichols: Nice.
Jake Wattenbarger: And then once my management team was behind me, it just filtered down to the project managers, to the superintendents, to even the foreman. mean, little things like my superintendents, they had these trucks that weren’t four-wheel drive, very basic models. These guys are bouncing around the jobs all the time. And they’re like, can I get another truck? I’m like, yeah, it’s that big of a deal to you. You just gotta care. Got an extended cab, got a four wheel drive truck. These guys live in that, you know, and it made sense. And doing those little things and listening, totally turned things around. So those little, think it’s really about caring is the essence of it.
Troy Latuff: Amazing. And taking some action. I was going to ask you the same thing on, know, so what was the first thing you did? And it sounds like that’s what you did is you asked questions. All right. Tell me, then act on it, not just ignore it, which is what the previous machine probably did. Right. They probably knew the same stuff. They just never did anything about it. Yeah.
Jim Nichols: very good
Jake Wattenbarger: Yeah, you got to ask questions. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. If you They did. That’s right. That’s right. Yeah. Yeah. If you, you know, to take the survey that I, that I had about the communication. And then I started with training. It’s like, I had to act. like, well, okay, let’s have a weekly meeting with my management team. Let’s make sure that, you know, just for, make sure that I attend other people’s meeting. I hate, I hate being, and it’s gotta be a productive meeting. I want an agenda. I want, it should be no more than an hour. You’ve got to get in and get out. Let’s just not admire the problem. Let’s get after it. And so that’s what. That’s what we did. then, you know, have an open door policy. Make sure that you get out and you talk to people, get out of your office, go walk the shops, go in, you know, go check out one of the job sites, you know, talk to people. You’re going to learn a lot of things. Not only are going to learn people, you’re going to be able to identify problems before they happen. There’s amazing what you can see. you’re just managing numbers, you don’t manage numbers, you manage people and you lead people. And if people are always looking at spreadsheets, it’s just not going to do it. This is a people organization.
Scaling Through Empowerment and Accountability
Troy Latuff: Do you, so that was three years ago, right? When you started that. what do you feel, and it’s easy to get, you know, stuck in the grind every day, right? And go, okay, tomorrow I’m gonna do that again. Or tomorrow I’m gonna go jump out in the truck and then, you know, I’m gonna do another survey or do some, get some feedback sessions going. But what do you think, you know, and I’m not putting you on the spot, but most business owners fall in the trap. They want to do all of that, right? ⁓ But most don’t.
Jim Nichols: Yeah.
Troy Latuff: Would you say, would you agree with that? And what would, what advice would you give people that have been doing it for 20 years and to just make themselves do it? And how would you do it?
Jake Wattenbarger: Yeah, there’s only 24 hours in a day and there’s only one of you, so you can’t do everything. And so if you want to scale, you’ve got to empower your team, but you also have to make them accountable. And that it comes with additional roles and responsibilities. And now that comes, you also got to pay him to do that. that’s what you got. You got to let go of being a micromanager. And sometimes you got to let him fail. You got to be in the guardrails, but you got to let him go. And this goes for everybody. then you can concentrate on the things that you need to do. Being in a leadership role, your main focus is to find them from direction and to make sure that you’ve got a good business development arm and so can keep those projects coming in. And then you’ve got to retain your talent and you’ve got to keep an eye on things. But you’re not the only person in there. If you’re the most important person in the organization, you failed as a leader. I should be able to be replaced. I do my job well, people should be able to step up and handle this company no problem because of the systems and the processes that I put in place. So that’s the ultimate goal. And that’s intentional and that’s just what I’m doing. So I would say for people that are looking, how can I do this? Well, you need to step back and find out what’s the most important. There’s a ⁓ quote from Jocko Willick, he said, hey, you need to relax, prioritize and then execute. And he’s so right. What’s the most important things that you should spend your time on? I should not be spending my time on, I don’t know. It’s like, oh, I gotta go make sure that so-and-so is updating his WIP report on time. Get your operations manager to do that. I don’t have time for that. That’s what the operations manager is gonna do. He’ll do it for you. Oh, I gotta make sure that those labor rates are updated and this and that. No, have the controller or have so-and-so. Like don’t work, yeah. You’ll be fine.
Troy Latuff: But like you said, you have to hold them accountable to it, right? So yeah, so.
Jake Wattenbarger: do. You do. Yeah. Yep.
Marissa: And then how often do you like reevaluate like for your survey and everything? Like, you know, you took action and it’s working out now. And then how often should you go back and do it again? Just and see if there’s any modifications we made.
Jake Wattenbarger: Yeah, so we did a survey when I first came on about two and a half years ago. We just did another one. So we’re going to find him. no, I’m not nervous. mean, you have to have some thick skin, but that’s OK. They have to have, you you got to have honest feedback and they can’t be scared of the repercussions. Not granted.
Marissa: Okay.
Troy Latuff: Are you nervous? You don’t know, right?
Jake Wattenbarger: You take things with a grain of salt. Some people, they just wanna complain. I instituted a monthly bulletin. ⁓ I just a one pager, I sent it out to the entire company. I have different sections. some people reply to me and some of it is, it’s good feedback. Some of it’s kind of comical. It’s like, click the barry agreement so that I should get a truck. You’re like, huh.
Troy Latuff: Ha ha ha ha.
Chad: Hahaha!
Jake Wattenbarger: Who are you? Okay, nice to meet you guys. I go like, why did you bypass your foreman? Why’d you bypass the superintendent? Why’d you bypass the operations? Oh yeah, you didn’t. They all gave you the reason and you didn’t like it. So now you came up to me and you’re using this as my open door policy as an excuse. So you gotta take things with a grain of salt.
Troy Latuff: Right.
Jim Nichols: Ha
Troy Latuff: Yeah.
Chad: Well, what would you say the high points and low points are ⁓ of those surveys? You know, the common theme. I’m sure it’s not, you know, more Snickers bars in the vending machines or something. So what is it that…
Troy Latuff: I wish it was all that. I wish that’s all it was.
Jake Wattenbarger: Yeah, I mean, least. Yeah, at least for the survey that we got the first one, it was it was communication. They want to know what are we doing as a company? Where are we going? And I want an update, but you have to be careful because you have to speak to the audience. So if you if you speak to your management team, it’s different than when you speak to an apprentice, right on the job. So you guys speak high level, but detailed enough that they that you give them direction, but not so detailed to confuse people.
Jim Nichols: Yeah, no kidding, that’d be easy.
Jake Wattenbarger: And so that, you know, to take this one page bulletin of the company, it takes me way longer than I would want it to take because I have to look at what my audience and what they’re getting that from, but it’s intentional. So that would be that one thing for the communication, you know, so that was a big piece and that that solved a lot. Another one was training. You know, people were, they want to know, hey, I want to get better at this. It could be, it could be a controls technician. It could be a project manager. It could be, an estimator to new enhancements system. So you’ve got to find out, and it can even be some of our sales staff, you’ve got to find out what that is, and then you got to act upon it. Like, okay, okay, tell me more about this training. So then you find out like, this is probably coming from service. I’m gonna go talk to some of my manager. Hey, where are you hearing this? Where are you hearing that? And then you’re like, oh, you know what? I think it’s this, I think it’s that. And then you say, oh, I think we need to get some control training, and we did that. Oh, I think we need to get… some folks to go into the project management school, you know, that ⁓ MCA puts up. Okay, we did that. We have a field leaders course that MCA puts in. Okay, let’s identify our strong performing foreman and let’s get into those classes. You just gotta do it. And once you do all those things, guess what? They’re pretty satisfied. But you really don’t know until a little, it’s like a lagging indicator until you do it. And then when you do it, is it enough? I don’t know, we’re gonna find out.
Troy Latuff: Well, you know, it’s interesting what you just said and you’ve said it a couple of times now for the first one and the second one. ⁓ So communication, I mean, that’s a life lesson, right? If you talk to people, everything can just work itself out, right? So you said training, which is usually it. What you didn’t say? Money. Right? So, and we hear about that all the time that we think as managers, everyone’s biggest bellyache is that they don’t make enough money. but that’s usually not even in the top five, right? So what would you say to that?
Jake Wattenbarger: right? Yeah, I think money will always come later. ⁓ But yeah, mean, even in my career, know, I’ve never left over money. I’ve left because I didn’t have a direction of where to go in the company. I didn’t know how I fit in and I just didn’t feel valued. It’s the same thing here. People feel valued when you communicate them. People feel valued when you invest into them and you… If you invest in people, that means you care about them. And yeah, there’s a Venn diagram, what’s best for the company and what’s best for the employee. Where it kind of meets in the middle is great. That’s what you’re always striving for. But yeah, you got to invest in them. And if, and that’s all about caring. If you show, if you communicate on a regular basis and you over communicate, you speak to the audience and then you get, and you invest in your employees to them, Hey, they care about me. They care enough about me that he talks and he communicates. and he’s also investing in my future. I want to stick with this company and then the pale company.
Troy Latuff: How many people work underneath you overall, just as an employee?
Jake Wattenbarger: We have about 250 people in our organization. I would say out of direct reports, I probably have got about eight direct reports.
Troy Latuff: but throughout the whole thing it’s 250 people. So the people that would get the newsletter or your bulletin, 250, yeah, so it’s a pretty big group. You don’t have the opportunity to talk to every one of them, right? So maybe shake their hand at a company picnic or something like that, but that’s where you need to, like you said, so you need to do it, but past your top eight, you’re probably making your way through the organization as best you can, but making sure they’re doing it. And that’s hard to do too, is making sure that you’re,
Jake Wattenbarger: Yeah, it’s about 250. It’s everybody. It’s everybody.
Marissa: Yeah.
Troy Latuff: Your next line is also feeling that is under that same thinking, right? That you need to talk to your people every week, at least, right?
Jake Wattenbarger: Absolutely. And I’ve been, I’ve been very fortunate to have a really strong management team. And you know, they keep me, they keep me on point. They’d like, Hey, Jake, you should probably get out to this project. Oh, wow. Why do you say that? Well, you know, this is a big project. They probably need to see this and that like, Oh, thanks for the advice, but you got to act on it. You just can’t like, yeah, whatever. No, you’ve got to act. these, you know, and I’ve been very fortunate with that. same thing, you know, sometimes, you know, we all have blind spots and sometimes on the management team, they’ll cover themselves too. They’d be like, hey, you know, you should probably take a look at, you know, that’s, you’re probably right. Hey, the next time you go out there, taking, taking with you on that job and let’s, call the superintendent too, so they can walk me around and introduce me some of the, you know, to some of the foremen or to some of our journeymen that are doing really, really well. ⁓ We usually make an intent to always, ⁓ talk with our apprentices and get to know them because we want them to come to Smith and Obey afterwards and stay there. So that’s what, yeah, so we typically, but the journeyman kind of in the middle, they kind of can get overlooked. It’s the new people and the old people, but right in the middle, they can get overlooked.
Moving Between the Field and the Boardroom
Troy Latuff: the ones that don’t make much fuss, right? So.
Jake Wattenbarger: Yeah, exactly. Yeah. And then they get overlooked. So you got to be very careful because you don’t you want to retain that talent. And just because they keep their nose down and they don’t cause any any issues, you you don’t want that silent quitting to happen. You got to make sure you’re happy.
Troy Latuff: Do you think? Yeah, that happens a lot. Yeah. So do you think it’s harder to get good talent or keep them? What would you say?
Jake Wattenbarger: I think in, and right now with some of the union stuff, I think it’s hard to get good talent. think once you got it, we can retain it. But that’s only if you have a good culture, right? If you don’t have a good culture, then retention is the hardest. But.
Troy Latuff: What do think is a good retention metric? So what do you use when you know you’re not going to keep everybody, right? in the, you know, so not the management level, but the skilled trades levels and union chef might be a little bit different, maybe not. I don’t know, but ⁓ what, what is the ratio? What’s a good benchmark for retention? What would you, you know, as an advisor, what would you say to a blue collar company?
Jake Wattenbarger: Yeah, and I look at retention, know, we’re looking at our key positions, right? We’re looking at, know, now specifically for the field, we’ve been looking at our foremen and our superintendents. So those would be, and then on the service side, it would be our field supervisors for our service technicians. We want to have retention there. I don’t want it to slip any below like 90%. I want to have it 100%. I don’t want to lose any of them. And because if you lose those feet,
Troy Latuff: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Okay. Yeah.
Jake Wattenbarger: Those folks, we found that a good service technician, if you’ve got a good field supervisor, they’ll take the customer with them.
Troy Latuff: Yeah, ⁓ yeah, for sure. Especially when there’s limited, right? On the services side, you might have thousands of customers. On their commercial side, you might have hundreds, tops, right? In a business like yours, it might even be fewer.
Jake Wattenbarger: Yes. Yeah, and I think the key is, know, when you deal with the union, ⁓ your apprentices and your journeymen are typically going to be, I’m union first, then that’s the company I’m working with. Because I’m going to switch companies, I want to go back, I to be starting with the union. You get into the foreman level, they’re like, they’re 60-40. They’re more for the company they’re working for, but they’re still union. And then you get into the superintendents, they are all about your company and they happen to be union people. So that’s really, know, we want to transition them to be more of the company rather than the union. That’s how we would on the field side, how we get the retention. And you do that by treating your folks right. Now you can’t treat everybody right, know, relationships are two-way streets. You know, so there’s always gonna be someone, there’s gonna be very, very talented and they’re always gonna be chasing dollars. Well, someone will give me 10 % rather than, I can get 12 % over scale here rather than 10%. Or so and so will do this and do that and like,
Troy Latuff: Yeah.
Jake Wattenbarger: Okay, then leave. Like, you know, they’re never gonna be happy. You look at their resume, they bounce around every other year that they’re leaving. Yeah, they’re good and they’re talented, but like, Don’t care.
Jim Nichols: Right.
Marissa: I have a question for earlier when you talked about the apprentices like that number from 300 to 12 and to make themselves more marketable. So what do you mean by that? Like what are some examples that think the apprentices could do to make themselves more marketable in that time?
Jake Wattenbarger: Yeah, you know, well, when I see it, it’s doing your time. So sometimes they’ll go to different trade schools already and they’ll get some experience in the construction industry. ⁓ Some of their, what the jobs that they’re looking at, sometimes they’ll go on as a laborer in the construction industry ⁓ to do some of those things. Other parts are that they’ll, hey, they can get in with a company and be an unadenture servant, you know? in the labor classification to try to become an apprentice or to try to break into the union. Those are all good stepping stones to do those things. Yeah, that’s usually people that stand out will do those things.
Troy Latuff: So when you look at your business, which is interesting, right? Cause you get to be part of pretty big, know, it’s just looking at your website, look at this building, we’re a part of this project. So it’s cool to able to have your friends in the car and point at that building and go, we built that or we were a part of that or whatever. So, but your business, it’s been around a long time, right? And you’re there for now and probably for a while, but what do you want your legacy to be there? Where do you want to take it? What’s next? When you’re looking at it you’re looking at it going, here’s where it is. Where do you want to
Jake Wattenbarger: Well, I I’d like to, you know, I wanted to retain the legacy and make sure that our reputation stays sound. But I’d also like to grab more of the market share, you know, ⁓ there’s some companies that are aging and some of these leadership, you know, folks, they have no plan for what they’re going to do later. I look at that as an opportunity. Maybe I can take some of their market share. Hey, you got some of their key leaders, you’re going, there’s no succession plan. So I would love to take more of the market share and grab talent and keep moving. My legacy here would be I wanna create a process and a system where I’m not the most important, but if I leave or eventually leave, I want it to be stronger than it was in the past like 25 years. I want it to grow. I just don’t want it to stay stagnant.
Jim Nichols: together.
Troy Latuff: You want your picture to be the biggest one on the wall, right? I’m just kidding.
Jake Wattenbarger: I don’t even know if I do it right, I’ll be forgotten because I’m not the most important and I go away. don’t even, you know, we have a president’s wall. I don’t even put mine on because it doesn’t matter. You know, you you gotta be a servant leader, a humble leader. Again, if I’m the most important person, then I have failed.
Jim Nichols: There you go.
Troy Latuff: No, yeah, there you go. Mm-hmm. What do you think is the hardest part about leading a company like yours or any blue collar business today?
Jake Wattenbarger: ⁓ I think it’s no one to speak to the audience, right? Sometimes you’re talking to the field and then the next minute you’re in a presentation with the Cleveland Clinic with the Bustin Suits and Ties on, you gotta watch your four letter ⁓ adjectives and adverbs and nouns ⁓ the way that you speak. So ⁓ that can always be kind of the hardest is just. quickly changing speaking to the audience and always speaking into their terms. what does it mean to them? And in this position here, because you’ve got engineers, you’ve got seasoned project managers, you’ve got really good coordinators that are like really IT people, then you’ve got ⁓ various folks in the field that are rough and gruff and you speak their language. know, like, what does this mean to you? Hey, we got this project. Okay, what? I don’t care what does that mean? Hey, we grew even by this. I don’t know what that means and I don’t care what it means. What does it mean to me? And then I got to speak to the board or my higher headquarters. And so that’s to me, it’s the most challenging is knowing how to speak to different audiences. And sometimes you got to pivot and do a 180 literally within five minutes.
Prioritizing Business Development With Your Management Team
Troy Latuff: You gotta be a chameleon. Yep, it really is. Are you involved with, so you spend a lot of time, it sounds like you spend a lot of time with your team and keeping them engaged and moving forward and on the same page and who-rah and all that, which is awesome, right? How much time do you spend on the client side? I’m just curious, right? So are you there nurturing those relationships as much or is that left to the development team?
Jake Wattenbarger: No, we don’t have a marketing team. We don’t have a business development team. Where historically in the past, that has always been retained with the CEO or the president of the company. But I come from a little bit of a different style. A lot of my management team have been in the business a long time and they have a lot of deep relationships. Some of them are on different levels than I have. And then…
Troy Latuff: Okay. Thank you.
Jake Wattenbarger: when I have been in different parts within the Cleveland market, different organizations, so I know different folks. So we have a team, when we have our management team, when we’re trying to go after and prioritize our business development, like, all right, hey, we’ve got this project, this project, it’s like, hey, who do you know in this? Who do you know in this? And sometimes it’s the operations manager. Sometimes it’s my director of pre-construction. Sometimes it’s the CFO, right? Sometimes it’s me. Depending on who has a relationship and where it’s at. I let them lead it and then I go in behind. That’s typically the way that I handle it. Because I can’t be the head business development guy all the time. don’t. And you’re probably aware is like I am not an extrovert. I’m an introvert. So I I do not like going out.
Troy Latuff: Yeah. Okay. Yeah. I don’t know, you’re doing pretty good, Jake. Well, that’s why I’m asking, right? But as a leader, sometimes you get, and I’m guilty of it, I’ll just say, so we have a lot of different clients doing a lot of different things. As much as I want to call all of them and say, hey, thank you for the business, we really appreciate it. I don’t, I should, but I don’t, right? But I wonder where you kind of fit in. Some of those things, maybe you’re a little bit hands off, but is there any customer interface that you?
Jim Nichols: Yeah, I think you’re doing dang good.
Chad: Yeah. ⁓
Jake Wattenbarger: Yeah
Troy Latuff: Kind of wish you did better or think you’re pretty good at it whatever. Advice, I guess, is what I’m looking for. Yeah.
Jake Wattenbarger: There’s already room for improvement. know, I, you know, the, the, the, the previous CEO, I still, I still talk to him and he has very good, strong relationships. And, you know, I do call him and I find out, you know, Hey, give me some advice here. You know, so and so, or this and that. And I do keep a running list of touch points that I put in my calendar that forces me like, Hey, touch base with so-and-so touch base with such and such. you know, ⁓
Troy Latuff: Yeah, that’s awesome.
Jake Wattenbarger: So I do that, it’s very intentional because, when I was on, I was over at university hospitals, I was a director of pre-construction. I was behind the scenes. I was the one that helped position projects for the board. And so people were always trying to get to me because there was gonna be an easy end to get in. But I know they didn’t care about me. They cared about my position. They were nice to me, it was, yeah, but it was so insincere. So my business development, I go to their,
Troy Latuff: Kind like the guy with the truck. Yep.
Chad: No.
Jake Wattenbarger: I always make it about sincere. It’s not about getting business. I want to get to know you personally and hopefully we relate, but I’m gonna be transparent with you. then hopefully over time, I would like to have a friendship if all possible. Not just, I just want a business, I don’t wanna be your friend. I have the opposite approach. It’s not as fast, but once I do it, it’s long lasting. So I take the slow approach rather than the quick turn.
Troy Latuff: Right, right. Yeah. It’s probably, yeah, well, it’s more meaningful if you can pull it off, right? But it’s staying organized to be able to do it.
Jake Wattenbarger: Yep. Yeah, there’s a lot of people that’ll waste your time if you allow it, you know, ⁓ and then you realize that they just want a free lunch or they want this, don’t waste your time. You know, I try to almost be like, hey, get me to say no and I hope they’re using me so I don’t have to waste my time with you anymore. You’re very transactional, you don’t care about it. That’s fine, yeah.
Troy Latuff: ⁓ yeah. Well, that’s what happens is Well, that’s what happens sometimes. You put that out there. Yeah, you put that out there sometimes, then they stop talking to everybody else and they just go to you. And that’s not, that wasn’t the point, right? So.
Chad: Ha ha.
Jake Wattenbarger: Right. Yeah.
Chad: Yeah, if you just want a free lunch, I’ll give you a gift card to Chick-fil-A. You don’t have to waste my time. Yeah, RB.
Jake Wattenbarger: Right. Yes. Yeah.
Troy Latuff: Or Arby’s.
Jim Nichols: Or Arby’s. Yeah.
Jake Wattenbarger: New Wendy’s will keep will keep it in Ohio. Columbus based.
Troy Latuff: There you go. There’s light going on in Ohio.
Marissa: I like Wendy.
Chad: Yeah, he’s got White Castle though at Ohio, man.
Troy Latuff: What’s who?
Jake Wattenbarger: Yeah, we might have it. Yeah.
Marissa: I have my cousin and Luna.
Troy Latuff: Who’s the best hire you’ve ever made? You don’t have to name names, but if you want to, you can.
Marissa: haha
Jake Wattenbarger: I know exactly one comes like, yeah, he’s a, yeah. I’d say a key hire totally changed my outlook. You know, ⁓ when you have a running partner and that someone that you can trust and you can bounce ideas off and has a blind and covers your blind spot. It’s a game changer. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. I met here at Smith and Obey. Yeah, for sure. There was a key hire here at Smith and Obey that I made. And if it wasn’t for him, I probably wouldn’t, I probably wouldn’t be in this position and talking to you guys right now.
Troy Latuff: Yeah? work for you today? Okay. Do you, is that somebody you knew before or they, no? All right, it’s just, it’s awesome.
Jake Wattenbarger: Nope. Didn’t know.
Jim Nichols: ⁓ nice. Well, how much of your management team, you you talked earlier about your key management team and how great they are. How many of those did you bring with you or did you hire and how many of them were there when you got there?
Jake Wattenbarger: They were there when I got here and I didn’t lose any of them.
Jim Nichols: Really? Wow. That’s great.
Jake Wattenbarger: Yeah, and that was setting, know, when I did that culture thing and rules and responsibilities and helping getting that back pay and getting that, that won them over. And then I saw their talent and then, you know, they always wanted to do more and allow them to do more. You got to hold them accountable. And yeah, I’ve had, I’ve had some, passionate discussions with some of them, but, you know, it’s all, it’s all, it’s all good. It was all meant, meant well. We came to an understanding and they’re performing, performing very, well.
Troy Latuff: Yeah. passionate discussions. There you go. I like that term. Okay, so now you probably see this one coming. ⁓ Who’s the worst hire you ever made? This one you have to name names. Just kidding.
Jake Wattenbarger: Yeah, I’m trying to think of as a higher.
Troy Latuff: where you’re like, I think we all have one where you’re like, that was, I don’t know, maybe it’s just me.
Chad: I like to forget mine. I like to forget my worst hours.
A Safety Lesson From the Sheet Metal Shop
Jake Wattenbarger: Yeah, there was a, yeah, we was, you know, I was, I was definitely, I wasn’t the hiring manager, but I was part of the interview process and there was definitely, yeah, a really, really bad hire. I would, I would say that now were the warning signs there? Maybe, maybe not. But wow. Yeah. When we did our, when we did our, you know, had an army background was an NCO like, this will be all good. Then, you know, like, ⁓ this would be fine. It was horrible. It was horrible. I mean, and our
Marissa: you
Jake Wattenbarger: and our annual drug screening popped. You’re like, are you kidding me? Yeah. And then the performance to go on top of it, you’re like, are you kidding me? Yeah.
Troy Latuff: Yeah, sometimes the best day of their life is during that interview. Chad teaches a class where he talks about red flags and green flags during the hiring process. And sometimes the big green flag just covers up all the little red flags. I’m guilty of it. I’ve got way more people that I wish I wouldn’t hire over the years.
Jake Wattenbarger: Yeah, I know it’s gonna happen. It’s gonna happen.
Chad: Hey, speaking of speaking of drugs, Jake, how well it’s becoming acceptable, right? And this is something I’m struggling with. Not me personally. But in the industry, it’s becoming widely popular to smoke weed, do marijuana, all different types of it. And a lot of blue collar trades and a lot of companies, they’re just accepting it. How, how is.
Troy Latuff: Hahaha
Jake Wattenbarger: Right.
Chad: How was your company, Anwin?
Jake Wattenbarger: Yeah, we don’t accept it at least, at least the collective bargaining agreement. That’s what we’re governed by with our unions and they do not allow it. ⁓ They do not allow that even though it’s allowed for recreational, but you cannot smoke it. If you’ve got our drug tests and if you get pot and if you pot for that drug test, you’re out and the unions are gonna back us up on that. And yeah, do they probably do it? I’m sure they do, but they have these random drug screening, but
Chad: Right.
Jake Wattenbarger: It’s funny how they all know what it is and how they can kind of clean themselves up. But you know, I had an incident. was walking out, I was working late. We had a second shift going to our sheet metal shop and I went to throw something away at the dumpster before getting into my car. And there was a guy, I think he just got off shift and I could just smell so much marijuana. And I’m like, hey, like, what are you doing? He’s like, well, I’m just relaxed. was like, you smoking marijuana? ⁓ no, no, I wasn’t. Okay, because I don’t know who I am. I’m the president general manager here. And who are you? Where are you working at? You know the collecting bar agreement doesn’t agree to this. like, you know I’m gonna follow up on this, right? You know this is unacceptable. It’s like, get the word out and I’m gonna go to the shop foreman right now and I’m gonna pull this up to the superintendent and I’ll make sure I put it out as a news blast, as a reminder that the collecting bar agreements says that you can’t do this. You just gotta be, you gotta take action.
Troy Latuff: Yeah. Especially in front of me. Yeah.
Chad: Yeah.
Jim Nichols: Yeah.
Chad: Yeah, the number one, I mean, it’s, it’s scary to me because like the number one, ⁓ thing that causes accidents, you know, distraction and complacency, guess would be number we were close number one and that causes both. ⁓ so
Jake Wattenbarger: Absolutely. And if there is an accident, at least on a union site, when our collecting the bargaining agreement and our policies, you immediately get drug screened. After you’re stabilized and everything, but there is a drug screen absolutely that’s gonna happen. if you have an accident and this and that, your workman’s comp and all of that stuff, it all changes. It all goes away. yeah. Yep.
Chad: Yeah.
Jim Nichols: goes away. Yeah.
Chad: It’s crazy times, man.
Jim Nichols: Interesting. What about, you know, speaking of
Jake Wattenbarger: Yeah, it is an interesting issue.
Jim Nichols: Speaking of, Chad brought up drugs, so I’ll bring up the other elephant in the room. What do you think about AI? How is that affecting you at all?
Jake Wattenbarger: You know, AI doesn’t really impact the field, but it definitely has impacted on our finance folks and even myself. I can do a little bit more with less. I don’t have to spend time on, you know, making these fancy board decks or the formatting. I’ll put that in AI and I’ll do it for me. Same thing with on my finance side. If my CFO or my controller need to do some analysis of that, they are using it. ⁓ If we want to come up with some, you know, legal reviews compared to this and and Redline compared to this. If we want to do some plan and specs, we can, our estimators will do it. Some of that, they’d be like, Hey, you know, analyze these plan and specs and make sure that we’ve kind of got things covered. But I haven’t seen it as a game changer. I see it as an enhancer, but you know, you hear these, these stories like, ⁓ you can use it. It’ll just estimate the entire project for you. No, it won’t because what we have, you know,
Jim Nichols: No, it won’t. Yeah.
Chad: No. No.
Jake Wattenbarger: We’re in the design assist area and we’re asking, our clients are asking us to give budget stuff and it’s literally an SD set. There’s hardly any narrative. There’s no details in the drawing. So you got to fill it all in. So you got to take your historical information and all the knowledge that they’ve got and then you got to start laying it out. And that can be subjective to get AI, maybe AI will eventually do it, but we’re not seeing it. And even then those mistakes, you know, the details will kill you.
Jim Nichols: And the follow up to that, and this is Troy’s probably favorite question, ⁓ chat GPT or Gemini.
Jake Wattenbarger: We don’t use either. ⁓ use Claude. Claude is extremely, Claude’s even best. I’ve used them all. I’ve used Chatgy Peets, I’ve used Grok, I’ve used Perplexity, I’ve used Copilot, and I’ve used Claude. I can tell you, I do the paid… ⁓
Troy Latuff: Was that my favorite question? Yeah.
Jim Nichols: ⁓ okay. Alright.
Troy Latuff: Yeah, for these guys, Clad would be better.
Jim Nichols: There you go, all right.
Troy Latuff: out.
Jake Wattenbarger: paid one because if you want to it for two reasons. One, it’s going to be better and two, it you behind that wall. So some of the confidentiality stuff, it doesn’t release it because they can’t scrape through that.
Troy Latuff: Yeah, Yeah, they’re all good at different things for sure. What’s that Marissa?
Jim Nichols: ⁓ nice. Yeah.
Marissa: That’s my first day.
Jake Wattenbarger: Absolutely.
Marissa: I’m going to try Claude
Troy Latuff: Heh.
Jake Wattenbarger: Yeah, Clomid is great. It’s great for modeling and doing some of your financial planning and analysis. It is absolutely great.
Chad: Merry birthday.
Troy Latuff: Okay, so to respect your time, let’s go around the horn with everybody to ask one final question for Jake.
Chad: I’ll go, so I drive my wife crazy with something, Jake, and that’s every time we travel around town, I go, I put an air conditioner in over there, I ran a service call over there, and I do that to her, and now she just tunes me out, right? So, but I’m just trying, I’m proud of it, right? So what project are you most proud of?
Troy Latuff: this company or ever.
Jake Wattenbarger: Yeah, no, there was, yeah, I would say ever. was probably the, ⁓ probably the most proud of, I was, I was over there and I was with the department of veteran affairs and there was a troubled outpatient clinic in Toledo, Ohio. And, you know, the, the, the developer is about to walk off the job. ⁓ There was, I look up, you know, the, on the ceiling, none of,
Chad: ever.
Troy Latuff: ever.
Jake Wattenbarger: None of the cabling is pulled for the CAT6 for the IT. ⁓ It was actually a dumpster fire. know, I’ve got, and then I had to quickly just, ⁓ and then to top it all off, this thing had to be opened by a certain date. And Marcy Kaptur is going against Dennis Kucinich in Ohio, and they’re having a runoff. And Marcy Kaptur was using this, it was in her district, and she’s already promised this outpatient clinic in Toledo for her folks. And there was already news and media scheduled on the opening date that was not moving. So you had all eyes on this project. And I’m coming on board to get this problem, you know, to get this mess, you know, to get it out of. Yeah. I mean, the details and there was no room for failure and what we had to do. Yeah. I’m the most proud of that just because I was able to negotiate everything and get things done and get it done on time. And yeah, there was just so much moving pieces.
Gathering Feedback From More Than One Data Point
Chad: pressure is up.
Jake Wattenbarger: that I had to have so many people working together, but we got it. Luckily, I had a lot of good workers that rolled up their sleeves and understood ⁓ what we’re up against, and they’re all team players, understood the end mission, and that’s what they did.
Troy Latuff: It’s kind like one of those home renovation TV shows where they’re all right up against the clock and as soon as the homeowner rolls up there, that’s the story, right? Yeah.
Chad: Excellent.
Jake Wattenbarger: Yeah!
Chad: Always.
Jake Wattenbarger: Absolutely. And that’s when we were, we were pressed right up against it. You know, I remember looking up that cabling. I’m like, guys, we’re going to do this. I was like, well, I go there as a quote, what’s going on. had to go schedule with the, with the, with the president of the, hospital there at the VA. think I had to go up to Ann Arbor, Michigan. That’s where they were. That’s what the president was. And we had to make a pitch of like, Hey, your it guys aren’t going in there and pulling this. Well, you know, this, I’m like, Hey, can I get your guys’ specs and can I just transfer the money? and then I’ll have them do it and I’ll put it on an accelerated schedule and I’ll use the stuff and add to my contingency dollar so we can hit their time. Yeah, you can do that. Like, all right, let’s go. Yeah, that’s like, let’s come with a solution. Luckily they bought off on it and you move.
Troy Latuff: There you go. That’s right. That’s awesome. Okay.
Jim Nichols: That’s very good. I have a question. Yeah, Jake. So that’s the professional side. Talk for a minute. do you think is your best accomplishment or your proudest accomplishment not related to business?
Jake Wattenbarger: Hmm. Yeah, I tend to not really celebrate my successes as it’s all, you it’s only what you did. You you can’t admire what you did in the past. You got to keep going. ⁓ But I think it’s, really, you know, your best accomplishments is really the respect and the trust that you’ve got with your, you know, who people in your close circle is. And I don’t let a lot of people in my close circle. And as long as I’ve got the respect is really what I’m going for. So. It’s more to me to that. can’t think of other paths to compete. There are probably some stuff I could name, but I tell you, I just don’t really think about it. know, any award, anything that I get, I don’t hang it up. I put it in the closet and I never look at it again. I literally, I get it. It goes right in there. My degrees, when I pass my PE, no, I throw it in the closet. I close it. Nobody cares. That’s yesterday. What are you doing for me now?
Chad: Thank you.
Troy Latuff: So Jim, that ribbon you got in fifth grade hurdles, you can probably put that ribbon away.
Jim Nichols: Very good.
Chad: You
Jake Wattenbarger: Yeah.
Marissa: Bye bye.
Jim Nichols: Yeah, well, it’s right there. It’s right next to next to perfect attendance in the sixth grade right there.
Troy Latuff: Well, that is too late.
Chad: Hello.
Troy Latuff: All right, Marissa.
Marissa: Hey, Jacob’s question is, ask everyone and it’s a really big question. So take a second to think about it if you need to. What is your favorite tool? your go to you love this one. Yeah, must.
Troy Latuff: Hahaha Gotta have.
Jake Wattenbarger: ⁓ Well, I don’t I mean I know one that I use a lot is probably just my cordless drill. I’m always using it for something. Yeah It’s always something yeah, but as as time goes on I’ve realized that you know, you got to have the right tool to do things Then I’m ⁓ I take more times I don’t have the right tool and I’m trying to use what I have rather say just cool down and spend the 50 bucks and get the I don’t have time for that and then you spend an hour of trying to use this if you had the right tool you do it easier so my
Troy Latuff: Makes sense. Yeah.
Marissa: What are you drilling?
Chad: ⁓ yeah.
Troy Latuff: You
Chad: That drives me nuts.
Jake Wattenbarger: My tool set has grown. I started off little, now it’s just getting bigger and bigger.
Troy Latuff: Ha ha
Chad: Yeah, that drives me nuts to see my guys do that. I’m like, why do you not have this? I like to do it with this.
Troy Latuff: Especially when you get that…
Jim Nichols: And if it’s one of those tools, if it’s a tool you only need once, you go to Harbor Freight and you pay 15 bucks for it, you know? Yeah.
Chad: Right. Yeah. Yeah. Or free.
Jake Wattenbarger: Yes, that’s true.
Troy Latuff: Yeah. Yeah. All right. So my question, okay, so that will so beyond the, you know, people getting into the trades, let’s talk, I want to hear your advice to people that are in that kind of in that mid career, right? Mid management want to develop, to get into it, to keep, you know, to get to director level, C level, different things like that, right? President level. What, what, what advice would you give them to take that sort of path? Cause that’s not easy, right? That’s just as hard as getting into it. or harder.
Jake Wattenbarger: Yeah, it is. ⁓ You have to be intentional about your career. You got to find out, know, look at, look at where you want to go. And then you’ve got to find out from those people. And it’s, and you got to have more than one data point, you know, so have a mentor talk with people. You’d be surprised at how strong your peer network is. But, you know, sometimes there’s gates for education. Sometimes there’s gates with certifications. Sometimes there’s another gate with certain amounts of experience. Sometimes it’s something else. You’ve got to find out what those gates are and if it really means to you, if it means that a lot to you, then start working at it. It doesn’t come by luck. It comes by an intentional thought process and you have to get after it. For me, I was like, okay, well, I want to be in this construction industry. All right, well, I’ve got to have experience as a project manager. All right, well, project manager, then what things… What things do I need to have certifications? Well, you know, I’ve got my certified construction manager thing. I was in healthcare. I got to get my CHC, my certified healthcare constructor, because that’s what matters in the clinic and what matters to university hospitals. Hey, you know, I deal with engineers and architects all the time in some of these organizations, even though they respect more of a professional engineer. Well, they get your PE, you know. Do I stamp any plans? Absolutely not. But I’ve got it. Do I advertise it? No. But if some people, but I… I needed those gates to get to where I wanted to go. Sometimes it’s not necessary and you think it’s a waste of your time, but you know, sometimes, hey, sometimes another gate, you might have to get your MBA, you know? I’m not saying that you have to, but, and there’s other ways to get there. Now you can always go in to having your own business and bypass everything. So you can say, hey, I want to be a pipe fitter. I’m going to work my way up. Then I’m going to open up my own business and I’m going to understand that. And then I’m going to become. you know, the owner and then I will learn from other folks and then I don’t have to have any of that stuff. You hire the people that have all that stuff. So you don’t need any of that stuff. I’m just talking about what we’re taught and how we look at things.
Troy Latuff: Yeah. Yeah, no, it’s awesome. And I think that’s where a lot of people that want something big for themselves, they get trapped, right? Because they just say, I want it. then, but they don’t do the actual homework to go, what do I have to do to figure it out? Right?
Jake Wattenbarger: And everything’s at your fingertip. It’s amazing. I don’t know what to do. Like, are you kidding me? I’m like, everything’s at your fingertips. Type in Google, how do I do this? So they go down those rabbit holes, start making lists, put it in a spreadsheet. Like, it’s not hard. It’s, yeah, it’s not complicated, but it’s hard work. You mean I can’t watch TV that night and I have to do some research? You mean I gotta read this and do that? Yep, yep. Yeah, it’s hard work.
Troy Latuff: Yeah, go on Claude. He’ll tell you exactly what to do tomorrow.
Marissa: Yeah.
Troy Latuff: Well, yeah, exactly. Okay, all right. Is there, well, I can’t thank you enough for spending some time with us today. It was really fun to talk to you, get to know you a little bit. ⁓ And is there any other parting words you’d like to share about you or the business before we go?
Jake Wattenbarger: I think the only parting words is, know, if there’s anything a word of advice I can give for being in leadership, it’s caring. If you care, if you truly care about the people, everything else will work itself out. It’s amazing if you care, they will forgive you of maybe you’re not the most technically competent, maybe you’re not the most polished speaker, but if you care, they will step up and they will help you and they’ll have you back. So I say if anything, a parting work, you you just gotta care.
Troy Latuff: There you go. They don’t care how much you know, they want to know how much you care, right? That’s the bumper sticker. Okay, all right, well thank you, Mr. Jake, I appreciate it. Thank you everybody. And we’ll see you again soon.
Jim Nichols: Very good.
Chad: Hear,
Jake Wattenbarger: That’s right.
Chad: Yeah.
Jim Nichols: Jake, nice meeting you.
Jake Wattenbarger: All right, Yeah, you too. Take care everybody.
Troy Latuff: Hang on one second here.
Marissa: Yeah.
Related Reading From The Blue Collar Recruiter
Go deeper on this topic with these guides from our blog.
- How HVAC Contractors Can Compete for Talent With Commercial Giants Like Ryder and FedEx
- Why Your Residential and Commercial Construction Firm Keeps Bidding Growth It Can’t Staff: And How to Break the Cycle
- How Companies Can Attract & Retain Top Skilled Trades Talent
- Employee Referral Programs for Blue Collar Hiring
- How to Build a Recruiting Engine Instead of Constantly Filling Jobs
More From BC Recruits and Trusted Sources
BC Recruits is our job board for skilled trades employers and job seekers. These guides and official resources add more context to this episode.
- What makes a great company culture
- Being an effective leader vs a manager
- Post a job on BC Recruits: reach skilled trades candidates who are ready to work.
- Create a job seeker profile on BC Recruits: get matched with trades employers hiring now.
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics: construction and extraction occupations: pay, outlook and training data for trades careers.
- OSHA Safety Management: how to build a workplace safety program.
More Episodes You May Like
- Women in Leadership in the Skilled Trades: Juli Blake: Juli Blake shares how she rose from dispatcher to leadership as a woman in the trades, and what it takes to advance.
- From Air Force to Home Services Business Owner: Jeff Rahn: Jeff Rahn shares his journey from the Air Force to building a successful home services business.
- Workplace Safety in the Skilled Trades in 2027: Jason Giefer: Jason Giefer on how workplace safety culture in the skilled trades has evolved, why empathy matters and what it takes to build a lasting…
- Browse the full podcast archive
Keep Exploring The Blue Collar Recruiter
- The Blue Collar Hiring System: learn how to hire skilled trades workers.
- Hire blue collar talent: find skilled trades employees for your business.
- Blue collar jobs board: browse current skilled trades job openings.
- Skilled trades courses: training for trades careers and business owners.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is Jake Wattenbarger on The Blue Collar Trades Show?
Jake Wattenbarger, President and General Manager of Smith & Oby (a Foundral company), walks through his unconventional path from military service into leading one of the Midwest’s most respected mechanical contracting companies. This conversation covers the 125+ year history of Smith & Oby, the real challenges of finding and keeping skilled tradespeople, and the cultural shifts reshaping the construction industry.
Where can I find Jake Wattenbarger online?
Jake Wattenbarger on LinkedIn (linkedin.com/in/jakewattenbarger), Website: smithandoby.com (smithandoby.com).
Is there a full transcript of this episode?
Yes. The full transcript with speaker names is on this page, below the episode summary.
Who hosts The Blue Collar Trades Show?
Troy Latuff of The Blue Collar Recruiter hosts the show, which features conversations with trades business owners and industry leaders about hiring, training, marketing, scaling and leadership in the skilled trades.
Where can I listen to The Blue Collar Trades Show?
You can listen with the player on this page or follow the show on Spotify at open.spotify.com/show/7IRt3IlB1m1pqOOpoLWtas. Every episode is also listed in the podcast archive at thebluecollarrecruiter.com/podcast/.
What topics does The Blue Collar Trades Show cover?
The show covers blue collar hiring, skilled trades careers, home service business growth, franchising, private equity, safety, company culture, sales, marketing and AI in the trades.
Where can I find blue collar jobs and skilled trades hiring help?
Browse openings on the blue collar jobs board at jobs.thebluecollarrecruiter.com, or visit the employers page at thebluecollarrecruiter.com/employers/ to hire skilled trades workers.